History · Investigations and price histories

SentriLock vs ShowingTime and BrokerBay: how the One Day Code integration ended on April 1, 2024, and what agents do now

On April 1, 2024 SentriLock stopped letting ShowingTime and BrokerBay generate One Day Codes for its lockboxes, after ShowingTime would not send it the real-time showing data it said SentriLock did not need to open a box. Booking still works, and an out-of-area agent now gets a One Day Code or a SentriConnect grant from the listing agent.

What stopped working on April 1, 2024?

One thing: the code. For years a buyer's agent without a SentriKey account could book a showing on a SentriLock-lockbox listing through ShowingTime or BrokerBay and get a One Day Code back with the confirmation. The showing service pulled that code from SentriLock's One Day Code API. From April 1, 2024, SentriLock shut that API to showing services. The Denver Metro Association of Realtors® told members on Friday, March 29 that starting Monday, April 1, SentriLock would no longer allow BrokerBay or ShowingTime to generate One Day Codes, and that anyone who wanted into a box would need a SentriLock app after booking.

Everything around the code stayed. ShowingTime kept scheduling appointments on SentriLock listings and its notifications did not change. Codes created before April 1 stayed valid. Lockbox owners, their office staff, assistants and team members could still make One Day Codes and FlexCodes and text them to whoever needed in. The only party that lost the power to make a code was the showing service.

What an agent could do on a SentriLock-lockbox listing, before and after the cutoff

You areBefore April 1, 2024From April 1, 2024
Booking a showing on a SentriLock listing in ShowingTime or BrokerBayBook as usual.Unchanged. Confirmations and notifications arrive as before.
Opening the box as a local SentriKey subscriberThe SentriKey app, or the code the showing service sent.The SentriKey app, during the appointment.
Opening the box as an out-of-area agent or affiliateShowingTime or BrokerBay generated a One Day Code when the appointment confirmed.Ask the listing agent for a One Day Code or a SentriConnect grant.
A code issued before the cutoffValid.Still valid. Nothing was revoked.
The listing agent's work per appointmentNone.May have to grant SentriConnect access or make a code for each appointment.
Who can make One Day Codes and FlexCodesOwner, office staff, assistants, team, and the showing services.Owner, office staff, assistants, team. Not the showing services.

Who owned whom when this happened?

Three companies, three owners. SentriLock has been 100% owned by the National Association of REALTORS® since December 2011. It started as a company NAR majority-owned, under a 2003 operating agreement that planned the handover, to give Realtors® an alternative in the lockbox market. ShowingTime has belonged to Zillow Group since October 1, 2021. Zillow agreed to buy it that February for $500 million and said in its announcement that ShowingTime would remain an open platform available to all industry participants.

BrokerBay closed three days after ShowingTime did. On October 4, 2021, Carrier Global Corporation completed its purchase of BrokerBay and made it part of Supra, Carrier's lockbox business and SentriLock's direct competitor. Terms were not disclosed. Nearly six months earlier, on April 13, 2021, SentriLock had launched a showing service of its own, SentriKey Showing Service, promising availability to every MLS and association by the third quarter of that year.

So by the time the One Day Code dispute began, the lockbox maker owned by the Realtor® association sold a showing service, and the two showing services it had been feeding codes to were owned by Zillow and by its rival in lockboxes. Nobody involved has said that ownership drove the decision.

What did SentriLock say it wanted?

SentriLock set out its terms in a letter to customers that DMAR published on May 12, 2023. From September 1, 2023 it would no longer provide integrations to third-party products that use its One Day Code API, and anyone a third party let into a box would have to use SentriConnect or SentriKey RE. Any provider of secondary access through SentriLock's APIs would also have to deliver “fully reciprocal data and functions in real-time”, so that a lockbox could only be opened around the approved appointment.

Section of a DMAR page republishing SentriLock's May 2023 notice: Who is Affected, What is Changing with September 1, 2023 in bold, the requirement that third-party access use SentriConnect or SentriKey RE, and the sentence that all providers of secondary access through SentriLock's APIs must deliver fully reciprocal data and functions in real-time
The May 2023 notice: September 1, 2023, an app for the person at the door, and real-time data from the showing service.

SentriLock's reasons were its own list, and it was a long one. Some showing services were sending codes to unlicensed people, and to people who had talked call-center staff into handing one over, after which SentriLock got the blame for a theft. A code cannot be revoked once sent. A code opens a non-FlexCode box more than once. A code returns no diagnostic data to SentriLock and gives it no Bluetooth connection to push firmware. And SentriLock wanted all appointment-based showing data sent to it in real time to run what it calls Access by Appointment. The letter said the changes asked of vendors were minimal and could be done quickly.

What did ShowingTime say?

One sentence, and it is the whole dispute. In a one-page notice to its MLS customers that the Northwest Iowa Association of Realtors® posted for members on March 20, 2024, ShowingTime wrote that SentriLock's proposed replacement “would require ShowingTime to share additional information about our customers and their showings that is not required for SentriLock lockbox access”. It said it remained open to another integration that would replace the codes. NWIA's post went up twelve days before the cutoff with the same three bullets DMAR would publish nine days later: a SentriLock indicator in the app and the email, a SentriLock app or a call to the listing agent for buyer's agents, and manual grants by listing agents for every appointment.

SentriLock's position was that the showing services should send it the appointment data and let it grant access through its own app. ShowingTime's was that the extra information was about its customers and their showings, and that SentriLock did not need it to open a box. Neither side published what fields were asked for. We found no statement from BrokerBay or Supra at all, and BrokerBay's old help pages are gone.

The associations in the middle said what they could. DMAR wrote that the change “may cause frustration” and that it was talking to SentriLock about alternatives. IRES MLS in Colorado told a subscriber on September 20, 2023 that the decision was SentriLock's, that IRES understood it was disruptive, and that IRES had got SentriLock to agree that IRES's own showing system could keep generating codes. IRES also put a price on the alternative: a SentriKey subscription at $9.95 plus tax a month, or the SentriConnect app for nothing.

How did September 2023 become April 2024?

In two accounts that do not quite agree. The letter DMAR published in May 2023 gives September 1, 2023 as the cutoff. SentriLock's CEO, Scott Fisher, writing on March 29, 2024, said the change “was first communicated out to our customers in June of 2023” and that the deadline had been extended “from October 1, 2023, to March 31, 2024”. Both are SentriLock's words. Take the earlier letter for the earlier dates: the cutoff slipped about seven months, and the three association and MLS notices we found from March 2024 reached members between two weeks and three days before it arrived.

SentriLock, ShowingTime and BrokerBay: the dates

DateWhat happened
December 2011NAR completes 100% ownership of SentriLock.
February 10, 2021Zillow agrees to buy ShowingTime for $500 million and says it will stay an open platform.
April 13, 2021SentriLock launches its own showing service, SentriKey Showing Service.
October 1 and 4, 2021Zillow closes on ShowingTime. Three days later Carrier closes on BrokerBay and folds it into Supra.
May 12, 2023SentriLock letter, via DMAR: One Day Code API integrations end September 1, 2023. Real-time data required.
August 24, 2023IRES MLS tells subscribers its own showing system keeps generating codes.
By March 18, 2024Realcomp: as of March 31, ShowingTime cannot issue codes for non-members.
By March 20, 2024ShowingTime's notice circulates: the replacement would require sharing customer data.
March 29, 2024DMAR's urgent notice. SentriLock's CEO letter: the deadline had already moved from October 1, 2023 to March 31, 2024.
April 1, 2024Third-party One Day Codes stop.
June 27, 2024SentriLock and Bright MLS announce SentriKey Showing Service for Bright and a Showing Hub integration.
October 2026ShowingTime's help still carries only the March 31, 2024 note. SentriLock markets against ShowingTime.

The CEO letter is the clearest statement of where things stood on the last business day before the cutoff. Vendors that adopted the updated API by March 31 would keep granting access to non-members through SentriConnect. Vendors that did not would “forfeit access to the access generation API”. And as of that Friday:

“Despite our outreach and extensions of timelines, our third-party vendors remain unwilling to implement the necessary changes.”

— Scott Fisher, CEO, SentriLock, in a letter published by the Denver Metro Association of Realtors®, · Source
DMAR web page headed A Message from SentriLock CEO, Scott Fisher, dated March 29, 2024, with the letter explaining the move from One Day Codes to SentriConnect, the deadline extension from October 1, 2023 to March 31, 2024, and the statement that third-party vendors remain unwilling to implement the changes, signed Scott Fisher, CEO
SentriLock's letter of March 29, 2024 as DMAR published it: the deadline had moved once, and the vendors had not.

What does an out-of-area showing look like now?

The booking is the same and the key is different. A local agent with a SentriKey subscription books in ShowingTime or BrokerBay and opens the box with the SentriKey app during the appointment. An agent from another board, an appraiser or an inspector books the same way and then needs one of two things from the listing side: a One Day Code made in the SentriKey app and texted over, or a SentriConnect grant.

A SentriConnect grant is an email address plus a start time and an end time, entered by the listing agent or office staff in the SentriKey app or website up to 14 days ahead, and revocable before the showing starts. The visitor downloads the free SentriConnect app, registers once, and presses the button on the box inside the window. The grant only works if the listing agent's association has switched SentriConnect on, the box is a Bluetooth model on firmware 50.44 or later, and the box is assigned to the listing. Every SentriConnect entry lands in the listing agent's access log.

Realcomp in Michigan described, as late as March 18, 2024, the version SentriLock had designed: the buyer's agent books in ShowingTime and ShowingTime grants SentriConnect access to their email address instead of sending a code. That version needed ShowingTime to adopt the API. It did not, so the grant became the listing agent's job, one appointment at a time, which is what the last bullet in the March 2024 notices told listing agents to expect.

Did SentriLock and ShowingTime ever reconnect?

Not on anything either company has published. ShowingTime's SentriLock help page still opens, in October 2026, with the note that as of March 31, 2024 SentriLock discontinued the ability for all third-party vendors, including ShowingTime, to generate one day codes, and that you may need a SentriLock app. Its Access Types page carries the same note in the future tense, never updated. Neither announces a replacement. ShowingTime still stores a SentriLock serial number and notes on a listing, and that is all.

SentriLock went another way. On June 27, 2024 it and Bright MLS announced SentriKey Showing Service for Bright subscribers and SentriLock's agreement to integrate with Showing Hub, the MLS-run interoperability layer built by Bright and CRMLS, with delivery expected that fall. That is a route around ShowingTime, run by the MLS. Whether Bright shipped it on time is not in any release we found.

Feature comparison table from SentriLock's website: SentriLock described as an integrated lockbox and showing platform, ShowingTime described as a third-party add-on owned by Zillow, ten feature rows with green check marks for SentriLock and red crosses for ShowingTime on the last five
SentriLock's own comparison page in October 2026 files ShowingTime under third-party add-on owned by Zillow.

SentriLock now sells against ShowingTime by name. Its comparison page heads the ShowingTime column “Third-party add-on owned by Zillow” and promises no third-party data silos or fragmentation. One page over, its APIs page has not caught up with 2024. It still tells associations that approved showing-scheduling vendors can retrieve One Day Codes for agents without a SentriKey account and that “you can continue to utilize these types of vendors without any interruption in services”. Read the 2024 letters, not that page.

Section of SentriLock's APIs page headed Call Center – Showing Scheduling Vendors, saying approved vendors have the ability to retrieve SentriLock's One Day Codes and that members can continue to utilize these vendors without any interruption in services, followed by four security bullets
SentriLock's APIs page in October 2026 still offers showing-scheduling vendors the One Day Code API, without interruption.

What should a listing agent or coordinator do about it?

Put the access method in the listing before the first request comes in. On a SentriLock listing, write in the ShowingTime or BrokerBay instructions that local agents use the SentriKey app and that everyone else gets a SentriConnect grant on request, with the number to text. Give office staff or an assistant SentriLock permissions so a grant does not wait for you to leave a closing. And check two things once, with your association: that SentriConnect is enabled for your board, and that your boxes are on firmware that supports it. An old box with no Bluetooth still needs a code.

Then keep your own record. The appointment lives in ShowingTime, the lockbox entry lives in SentriLock's access log, and the code that used to tie one to the other is gone. When a seller asks who was in the house on Saturday, you are the join. The same goes for the deal itself. Two vendors fell out, the final notice went out in days, and the out-of-area showing changed on every SentriLock listing booked through them. A closing file that sits inside one vendor's contract is exposed to exactly that. DeedSpring keeps the executed contract, the deadlines, the documents and the messages on a closing you control, downloadable whole as a ZIP or one merged PDF, month to month, from $15 a month for one closing or $25 a closing on Standard.

New TC checklists, templates and deadline guides

Get a short note by email when we publish one.

Now and then, a short note on transaction coordination from DeedSpring. Reply to any of them to stop.

Case study · Investigations and price histories

KW's DocuSign Rooms shutdown: what happened to agents' files on July 14, 2026, and what to do now

Keller Williams' corporate DocuSign contract ended on July 14, 2026. Documents already in a Command Opportunity stayed, envelopes sent for signature are still downloadable from a read-only account, and documents that only lived in a DocuSign Room are gone unless you downloaded them or your Market Center ran the API Nation backup. Here is what to download now, who holds the office copy, and how to keep your files out of the next vendor switch.

Explainer · MLS, IDX and listing data

IDX vs VOW vs BBO: which MLS feed your tool is on, and what each one can show

IDX is the public-advertising feed behind your website, VOW is the registered-client feed with deeper data, and BBO is the brokerage's internal feed with the most. Here is what each one carries, how stale it may be, who can opt out, and why your tool shows less than the MLS.

Research · Investigations and price histories

Transaction software price moves since 2024: Nekst, tcDocs, ListedKit and SkySlope DigiSign

Nekst's solo plan went from $29 a month to $79 plus a $299 onboarding fee. ListedKit dropped its $49 subscription for credits that now cost $14.99 each. SkySlope DigiSign went from free to $35 a year to $75. tcDocs added $11 to $16 a month. Every price, dated from the vendor's own page, and what to get in writing before you sign.

Research · Investigations and price histories

dotloop's uptime page stopped in October 2023. What the status pages of transaction vendors actually show

dotloop's only uptime page lists November 2022 to October 2023 and has not changed since at least April 2024. SkySlope's status page shows 100% and three notices this year, while a third-party monitor logged a 42-minute June outage it never posted. Lone Wolf and Follow Up Boss post the most. Where to look for each vendor, and what each page can and cannot tell you.