Comparison · Software comparisons and alternatives
CINC vs Sierra Interactive: routing, follow-up and team operations
CINC is a lead-generation service with the CRM, website and routing bundled into an Order Form you price on a call. Sierra Interactive is IDX website and CRM software from $299.95 a month on a 12-month agreement, and it is the pick for a team lead who wants the number before the demo.
CINC, DeedSpring and Sierra Interactive on the points a team lead decides
| Decision | CINC | DeedSpring | Sierra Interactive |
|---|---|---|---|
| What you are buying | A lead-generation service with the CRM, website and routing bundled in | Transaction coordination from signed contract to keys | IDX website and CRM software. Ad management is an optional add-on |
| Published price | None. Every tier says Request Pricing. CINC AI from $200/mo, Dialer $75/mo | $15 a month for one closing a month | $299.95 a month for Starter, one user, paid annually |
| What you sign | An Order Form with an Initial Term, then month to month | Month to month | A 12-month agreement. $500 setup fee if you pay monthly |
| Who sets lead routing | Broker-level users, under Agents and Lead Routing | Nobody. It starts at the signed contract | The Primary Manager or a Manager, under Leads and Lead Routing |
| Speed-to-lead call | Switchboard Sarah phones agents one at a time. Press 1 to take the lead | None. It starts at the signed contract | First to Claim phones every agent at once. Needs the Sierra Dialer |
| A lead nobody calls | Auto-Reassign moves it on. Support or your Account Manager must switch it on | Hourly check flags a stalled task on Today and the closing | An automation creates a task for the Primary Manager to reassign it |
| Automated follow-up | AutoTracks drips. CINC AI texts from $200/mo, enabled by your Account Manager | The AI coordinator drafts the chases. A person approves them by default | Action Plans. Lead Engage texts for $199/mo, not on Starter |
| After the contract is signed | A Deals Dashboard, in beta | Reads the contract, sets the deadlines, chases lender and title | A transaction record for reporting |
What are you actually buying from each?
CINC sells the leads first. Every tier lists Google and Facebook buyer and seller leads, List Cast and remarketing under Lead Generation Products, and CINC's lead generation page says its team manages over $30 million a year in ad spend. The terms say what that means on the invoice. The Order Form lists, where they apply, a set-up fee, hosting fees, an advertising fee made of ad spend plus a management fee at a monthly amount you pick when you order, and telecom fees. All of it is non-refundable.

Sierra sells the website and the CRM, and the ads are a separate decision. Its pricing page files ad management under add-ons: Google PPC at a 10 percent monthly management fee on a minimum $500 of spend, Facebook management at $75 or $200 a month. The Google Ads help page describes an in-house team that builds and runs the campaigns, starts nothing without your explicit approval, and tags the leads Sierra PPC. A Sierra team can run its own ads, buy Sierra's management, or buy none. A CINC team is buying the ads.
What does each cost, and what do you sign?
CINC publishes no plan price. The tiers are Solo for one user, Ramp for up to four, Pro for up to 49 and Select for 50 or more, each with a Request Pricing button. The agreement runs for an Initial Term set in the Order Form, then renews month to month at the prevailing rate. Cancellation notice must arrive before the term ends and takes effect at the end of the next full month or billing cycle. Leave without cause before the Initial Term ends and you owe the remaining fees for it.
Sierra publishes three packages. Starter is $299.95 a month with one user, Essential $399.95 with three, Growth $599.95 with five, all on a 12-month agreement paid annually up front. Monthly billing is $359.95, $474.95 and $724.95 plus a one-time $500 setup fee that annual billing waives. Extra users are $75 each on Starter, $60 then $25 on Essential, and $20, $10 and $5 on Growth as the headcount grows. Three people on Starter cost $449.95, so Essential at $399.95 is the cheaper package for three. Subscriptions renew automatically, and canceling goes through the billing team under the signed agreement.

Build the full Sierra invoice for a five-person team and it is still a number. Growth at $599.95, Lead Engage at $199, and Google PPC at the $500 minimum plus the $50 management fee come to $1,348.95 a month, $500 of it ad spend. The CINC invoice has the same lines and only two of them are public. Get the Order Form before the demo ends.
How does a new lead reach an agent?
In CINC, routing is a broker's job. A Broker-level user opens the Agents tab, then Lead Routing, and turns agents on with a weight, a monthly cap, availability hours, price points, areas and lead sources. Availability cannot cross midnight, and a lead that arrives when no agent is on goes to the site owner. The speed-to-lead option is Switchboard Sarah, which phones agents one at a time, plays the lead's name, price point and area, and connects whoever presses 1. While it runs it overrides every other routing criterion, and CINC says it is a poor fit for city or ZIP routing and for ponds.
In Sierra, routing is a manager's job. Lead Routing Rules are account-level and need Manager permission. Rules run top to bottom until one matches, on source, tag, lead type, location, price range, property type or site. Each rule picks a distribution type: auto-assign, claim with timeout, instant call, first to claim, or a lead pond. First to Claim phones every agent in the rule at once and gives the lead to the first who answers and presses 1. It needs the Sierra Dialer, and each answered call can be billed a minimum of one minute even for the agents who lose. Two things sidestep the rules: a tracking link overrides them, and a lead who registers on an agent's own subdomain goes to that agent.
What happens to a lead nobody calls?
CINC reassigns it for you. Auto-Reassign moves a lead that no agent has attempted to contact within a set time to another agent under the same routing rules, or, with Sink or Swim, into a pond where any agent with access can work and claim it. The help page spells out the catch: you have to contact support or your Account Manager to get the feature enabled. CINC also warns that Auto-Reassign and its AI texting do not pair well, so a team running both has to pick.
Sierra hands the problem to a person. Its accountability automations are built by a Manager, and the first scenario Sierra documents fires a day after registration if the agent has not made a call. The action is a task for the Primary Manager to reassign the lead. Sierra puts it plainly: agents should know a missed call triggers a manager task. Sierra's ponds are tighter too: a lead one agent is working is hidden from the others, a manager caps how many pond leads each agent can work, and a claim can need a manager's approval with a reason.
Who owns the follow-up?
CINC's drip layer is AutoTracks: sequences of emails, texts and agent reminders in three shapes, Sequence, Calendar and Checklist. A Broker can make an AutoTrack Public, and a Public AutoTrack's start and stop triggers then apply to every agent's leads sitewide. The AI layer is CINC AI, called Alex. Your Account Manager switches it on and quotes the price, the pricing page says from $200 a month, and you cannot edit its scripts. Alex hands the lead to the agent when it is ready, and one manual text from an agent ends its conversation. CINC strongly discourages running Alex alongside Auto-Reassign or Switchboard Sarah.
Sierra's drip layer is Action Plans: sequences of emails, texts, calls and tasks. Fully Automated plans run with no manual steps and pause when the lead texts, emails, calls or submits a form. Building one needs the Primary Manager or a named permission. An account can hand-assign 50 fully automated plans a day, support can raise that to 500 on request, and plans applied by a routing rule have no cap. The AI layer is Lead Engage: two-way texting for up to 12 months at $199 a month on a 12-month commitment, on Essential and Growth only. The Primary Manager decides which agents can use it, its responses cannot be customized, and once the lead replies the agent takes over.
Who sees what on the team?
CINC has two default roles, Agent or Partner and Broker, and the Broker grants the rest as permissions. Team Leader lets an agent see every lead in the dashboard regardless of assignment, which CINC pitches at a team admin or ISA. Can Assign lets an agent reassign leads, which by default only Brokers can do. For accountability, Brokers and Team Leads open the Call Summary report under Launchpad: each agent's last login, dials against leads and voicemails.
Sierra has four user types. One Primary Manager per account holds billing and is the only user who can permanently delete leads. Managers build routing rules and account-wide action plans. Agents work their own leads and build personal plans only. The call report is the Dialer Dashboard, per agent, with dials, valid conversations and appointments per hour, and it counts only calls placed through the Sierra Dialer. Manually logged calls and First to Claim calls are left out.
What happens after the contract is signed?
Both stop at the signature. CINC's Deals Dashboard shows active deals by stage and a potential commission from the closed price and percentage, and the help page calls it a new feature that is only in beta testing. A Sierra transaction is added when a lead's status is set to Closed and holds a lead type, a date, an amount and an agent, for reporting. Neither reads the inspection deadline off the contract or chases the lender.
DeedSpring does. Upload the executed contract and its coordinator reads the price, deposits, contingencies and dates into deadlines, checks every active file every hour, and chases lenders, title and inspectors. By default the messages it drafts wait for someone on your team to approve them, and anything sensitive or negotiable is always a draft.
Which should a team lead choose?
Choose Sierra Interactive when you want to see the price before the call, when you already run your own ads or want to decide later, and when a Manager on your team will own the routing rules and the action plans. Put the $500 setup fee against paying the year up front, and budget Essential rather than Starter once you are three people.
Choose CINC when you want one vendor to run the ads and the CRM behind them, you have a Broker-level user who will set routing and grant permissions, and you can sign an Order Form whose price and term you learn on the call. Before you sign, get three things in writing: the Initial Term, the monthly advertising fee split into spend and management, and whether Auto-Reassign and CINC AI are switched on.
Weighing Follow Up Boss too? We have set it against CINC and against Sierra Interactive.

How we compared
We read both vendors' pricing pages, terms and help articles on lead routing, reassignment, follow-up automation, AI texting and user roles, taking Sierra's pricing and terms from dated saved copies because its site blocks our region. We compared what each sells, what you sign, and who owns each step.